Quality in Primary Care Open Access

  • ISSN: 1479-1064
  • Journal h-index: 29
  • Journal CiteScore: 6.64
  • Journal Impact Factor: 4.22
  • Average acceptance to publication time (5-7 days)
  • Average article processing time (30-45 days) Less than 5 volumes 30 days
    8 - 9 volumes 40 days
    10 and more volumes 45 days
Reach us +32 25889658

Research - (2023) Volume 31, Issue 6

Reducing Health Care Associated Infections in a Neonatal Intensive Care Unit through Quality Improvement Approach, Tibebe Ghion Specialized Teaching Hospital, Bahir Dar University, Bahir Dar, Ethiopia-Mirror of the Health Care Quality
Tesfaye Taye Gelaw1*, Alamirew Alebachew Gessesse1, Amare Aschalew Yehuala1, Yiheyis Genetu Belay, Shitahun Fentie Tilahun, Senay Zerihun Mengste, Zebenay Bitew Zeleke, Ibrahim Muhammed Getahun, Mensur Azeze Getahun, Aemiro Adebabay Berihun, Bezza Ademe Akalu, Behayilu Yizengaw Muluye, Minichil Aschale Demil and Sefina Abdie Muhammed
 
1Department of Pediatrics and Child Health, School of Medicine, Bahir Dar University, Ethiopia
Department of Surgery, Bahir Dar University, Ethiopia
 
*Correspondence: Tesfaye Taye Gelaw, Department of Pediatrics and Child Health, School of Medicine, Bahir Dar University, Ethiopia, Email:

Received: 06-Nov-2023, Manuscript No. ipqpc-23-18627; Editor assigned: 08-Nov-2023, Pre QC No. ipqpc-23-18627 (PQ); Reviewed: 22-Nov-2023, QC No. ipqpc-23-18627; Revised: 27-Nov-2023, Manuscript No. ipqpc-23-18627 (R); Published: 04-Dec-2023, DOI: 10.36648/1479-1064.31.6.42

Abstract

Background: Health-care-associated-infections are infections occurring while receiving health care that first appear 48 hours or more after hospital admission, or within 30 days of receiving health care.
Objective: Measure the impact of quality improvement interventions on health-care-associated-infection in the Neonatal Unit of Tibebe Ghion Hospital.
Method: We conducted pre-post Interventional Study between February 01, 2022 and May 01, 2023. Multifaced interventions; implementing recommended minimum NICU standards, re-enforcing WHO IPC Guideline and Hand Hygiene practice, were introduced. NICU Standards achieved, Hand hygiene compliance, WHO IPC guideline Implementation and Health-care-associated-infections were surveyed. Comparison of Health-Care-associated-infection rates before and after the intervention was conducted.
Results: Recommended NICU Design standards status was improved from 8% pre-intervention to 79% and 79.5% during and post-intervention respectively. Hand Hygiene compliance in the unit was 10% pre-intervention and improved to 79.5% and 81.3% during and post-intervention respectively. The WHO IPC implementation status was 15% pre-intervention and maximized to 58% both during and post-intervention. These package of interventions were associated with reduction of Health-Care-associated-Infections. [X2 (Degree of Freedom=1, Sample Size=432) 8.2, p=004]
Conclusion: Infection Prevention practice, Hand Hygiene Compliance and improving NICU Design standards were associated with decrease in health-care-associated-infection rates.

Keywords

NICU; Health care associated infections; Quality improvement

Introduction

Health Care-Associated Infections (HCAIs) are infections that occur while receiving health care, developed in a health care facility that first manifests 48 hours or more after hospital admission, or within 30 days after having received health care [1,2]. HCAIs reflects the extent of health care quality in the health care system [3]. It is the leading, preventable adverse event in acutely ill patients and is associated with considerable morbidity, mortality, and additional use of resources [4,5]. HCAIs ruin patient expectations of quality medical care and increase negativity towards the formal health system in favour of other options, especially since the costs of HAIs are borne by the patients themselves in many developing countries [6]. It also causes unnecessary pain and suffering for patients and their families, prolong hospital stays and are costly to the health system [7].

Reducing the risk of HCAIs faced by populations in developing countries is a major priority of the WHO [8]. Successful approaches for preventing and reducing harms arising from HCAIs involve applying a risk-management framework to manage ‘human’ and ‘system’ factors associated with the transmission of infectious agents.

HCAI is a potentially preventable adverse event rather than an unpredictable complication and it is possible to significantly reduce the rate of HCAIs through effective infection prevention and control practice, Hand Hygiene Compliance, meeting minimum NICU design Standards for level III and IV NICUs and other evidence based Interventions [9-13]. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the impact of Quality improvement intervention in reducing HCAIs among neonates in NICU.

Methods

Setting and Participants

The study was conducted from February 1, 2022 to May 01, 2023., in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit of Tibebe-Ghion Specialized Hospital, a teaching hospital of Bahir Dar University, a large referral center that provides primary and tertiary medical care for residents of Bahir Dar city, Amhara National Regional State and the surrounding National Regional States.

Approximately 2,000 neonates are admitted annually to the fifty six (56)-bed NICU. There was scarcity of Hand-washing facilities throughout the unit. Though limited practice, use of alcohol-based hand rub has been the primary method for hand hygiene. The NICU ward Infrastructure design is lacking the minimum recommended NICU Design Standards [13,14].The WHO recommended IPC guideline Implementation status was below the expected (0-200) [10].

Study Design

Institution based Pre-Post-Interventional study was conducted. The study was conducted in three phases. The Baseline phase (Phase 1, 6 months) consisted of studying the Health Care set up as per the recommended minimum NICU Design standards for level III and IV NICUs, assessing the Unit’s WHO recommended Infection Prevention and Control Practice implementation status, surveying Health Care Workers (HCWs) Hand Hygiene Compliance, and conducting Pre-Intervention prospective data collection by simple random sampling technique and analysis of the health care associated infection rate and its associated factors [9-11,13]. The intervention phase (Phase 2, 6 months) was approached through “the Model for Improvement approach” and was based on the results of Phase 1 assessments. Continuous prospective surveillance of HCAIs was performed throughout the entire phase. Hand Hygiene Compliance, the WHO Infection prevention and control guideline Implementation and the recommended minimum NICU Design Standards assessment were being done every two weeks. The Follow up Phase (3 months) was conducted in phase 3 of the study with no active intervention. Prospective data collection by simple random sampling technique was conducted to assess the post intervention status of HCAI.

Baseline study (Phase One): From February 01, 2022-July 31, 2022: Pre-Intervention data for Sociodemographic, HCAIs associated factors, and comorbidities were collected by simple random sampling technique. Structured observation and assessment sessions were conducted to evaluate the Infection prevention practice and Hand Hygiene compliance using the WHO IPCAF tool and Hand Hygiene Compliance assessment formats. The NICU design standard was also assessed as per the recommended Minimum standard for level III and IV NICU care [13]. Descriptive analysis was done. The output from the analysis was used to formulate high impact low cost interventions to be implemented in phase 2 of this study to reduce the HCAI incidence.

Intervention (Phase two): From August 1, 2022-January 31, 2023: We Used “The Model for Improvement Approach” to implement change ideas/interventions which were generated during root cause analysis/RCA sessions after the baseline/ Phase one assessment. Aim statement formulated, root cause analysis done to generate change ideas from the phase one findings and prioritized by focusing matrix for implementation. Using the Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) Cycle methodology, change ideas were implemented simultaneously with small scale and escalated subsequently throughout the intervention phase to implement at larger scales [15].

The Change Ideas generated were grouped under three umbrella categories; Hand Hygiene Practice, Infection prevention and control guideline implementation status and the recommended minimum NICU standards. Hence; we use the WHO Hand hygiene Compliance Checklist, the WHO Infection Prevention and Control Assessment Framework (IPCAF) and the Recommended NICU Design Standards for level III and IV NICUs [9-11,13]. The interventions and HCAIs rate were being monitored every two week and Plotted to monitor the process throughout the Intervention phase.

Four teams were organized with a team leader to handle HCAI surveillance, Hand Hygiene Compliance assessment, Infection Prevention and control Practice assessment and the NICU Design standards assessment. The changes from the interventions were plotted to monitor the process and analyse the significance of the intervention by run chart [16].

Minimum recommended NICU design standards for level III and IV NICUs: 13 surveys including the baseline assessment were conducted by the team who were trained before the intervention period to assess the unit as per the recommended NICU Design Standards. They see the status of the unit against list of the standards in team and score it from hundred (%) twice in a month. Percent achieved in the implementation status of the NICU Design Standards was considered as process indicator and plotted on run chart to follow progress [9,12,13].

Hand hygiene compliance: 13 surveys including the baseline assessment were conducted by the team assigned and trained to assess, monitor and provide feedback on the status. The Hand Hygiene compliance was assessed using the WHO Hand Hygiene compliance assessment checklist [11]. The team was assessing the health care providers and auxiliary staff practicing in the unit after providing onsite trainings. Assessment was being done twice in a month. Percent achieved during assessment was used as process indicator and Plotted on run chart to follow progress.

Infection prevention and control guideline implementation: Using the WHO Infection Prevention and Control Assessment Framework (IPCAF), surveys were done to assess the implementation status of the WHO Infection Prevention and control by the team trained and deployed to assess, monitor, and provide feedback. The tool categorizes facilities level in to four after computing the scores (Inadequate (0%-200% or 0%-25%); Basic (201%-400% or 25.1%-50%); Intermediate (401-600 or 50.1%-75%) and Advanced (601%-800% or 75.1%- 100%) [10]. Surveys were being done twice in a month for a total of thirteen times including the baseline. Percent achieved was used as process indicator and plotted on run chart to follow progress.

Surveillance of health care associated infection: The team conducted prospective surveillance of Health Care associated infection. All neonates were being followed from admission to discharge. HCAI was diagnosed by chart review, direct patient evaluation, laboratory finding interpretations and information from the round team [17,18]. Updated information was provided to the research team on twice in a month basis. Percent achieved every two week was used as process indicator and plotted on run chart [16,19].

Follow up (Phase three): From February 01, 2023-April 30, 2023: Sociodemographic parameters, HCAIs associated factors and comorbidities were collected for the determined sample size on prospective basis using simple random sampling technique. This was computed with the pre-intervention.

Sample Size and Selection

Sample Size formula for Two Independent Samples with Dichotomous Outcome was used to estimate the difference in proportions between two independent populations (HCAI before Vs. after intervention). Level of significance=5%; margin of error=0.05%; proportion of HCAIs (one category=0.076). With this, sample size was calculated to be 216 for each of pre-and Post-Intervention groups. Simple random sampling method using Microsoft excel was used for sampling.

Exclusion Criteria

Newborns admitted after diagnosis of HCAIs at some other health facility.

Newborns with Incomplete documentation.

Newborns whose caregivers were not willing to participate in the study and

Newborns who stayed less than 48 hours before discharge.

Definitions, Diagnosis and Classification

Health care associated infections(HCAIs): Are infections that occur while receiving health care, in a hospital or other health care facility that first appear 48 hours or more after hospital admission, or within 30 days after having received health care [2,20,21].

Hand hygiene: Handwashing, antiseptic handwash/hand rub, or surgical hand antisepsis [22].

Hand rubbing: With an alcohol-based (75% vol/vol, isopropanol) preparation of chlorhexidine gluconate (0.5%) was defined as the standard procedure for hand hygiene before and after patient care activities, unless hands were visibly soiled [23].

Hand washing: Is the act of cleaning one’s hands with the use of any liquid with or without soap for the purpose of removing dirt or microorganisms [22].

Diagnosis: HCAI is considered, when reported as infection acquired while receiving Medical care based on culture confirmation or clinical and laboratory methods [17,18].

Classification

Blood stream infections (BSI): A first positive blood culture ≥ 48 hours after hospital admission or within 48 hours of discharge from hospital [26].

Lower respiratory tract infections: Respiratory decompensation with new and persistent infiltrates on CXR or Infants with worsening gas exchange and at least 3 of the following [27]:

• Temperature instability with no other recognized cause.

• min (white blood cell count <4000/min)

• Change in character of sputum or increased respiratory secretions.

• Apnea, tachypnea, nasal flaring, or grunting.

• Wheezing, rales, rhonchi, or cough.

• Bradycardia (<100/min) or tachycardia (>170/min).

Surgical site infections: Infections occurring up to 30 days after surgery and affecting either the incision or deep tissue at the operation site [28].

Urinary tract infections: Catheter-associated urinary tract infection (CAUTI) is defined as a urinary tract infection (UTI) where an indwelling urinary catheter was in place for more than 2 calendar days on the date of event, with day of device placement being day 1, and an indwelling urinary catheter was in place on the date of event or the day before [29].

Skin and soft tissue infections: A patient without any evidence of infection on admission and who was culture positive >48 h after admission [30].

Nosocomial diarrhea: Diarrhea that develops during a hospital stay or up to 3 days after discharge [31].

Statistical Analysis

“The Model for Improvement Approach” was used to do the intervention (phase two) [15]. Goal was set using the best achievements worldwide so far [32]. Run chart was utilized to determine the statistical significance of the intervention and monitor process indicators during intervention [16].

Phase one and three were compared to evaluate the impact of the intervention implemented during phase two on the prevalence of HCAIs. Categorical variables were compared using Chi-squared test. Adjusted odds ratio (95%CI) was computed for variables. P-value<0.05 was considered statistically Significant. We used SPSS Version 25 for analysis.

Ethical Considerations

Our protocol was approved by Bahir Dar University, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, IRB with protocol number 793/2023. Formal letter of cooperation was secured from Tibebe-Ghion Specialized Hospital. Informed consent to participate in the study was obtained from all parents or legal guardians. All information collected was kept in the way that could not interfere in personal confidentiality during data collection, analysis and then after.

Results

Socio-Demographic Characteristics of Patients

432 neonates (216 neonates in each pre-and Post-Intervention group) admitted in the unit for ≥ 48 hours who were selected and fulfil the inclusion criteria were included in the analysis. Patient Socio-Demographic Parameters are described in Table 1 below. Case mix as estimated by Age of the newborn, Gestational age, Birth Weight, Gender, Mode of Delivery, Place of Delivery, and Maternal age was comparable over the study period (both Pre- and post-Intervention).

Table 1: Socio-Demographic characteristics of Neonates across study Phases: Bahir Dar University Tibeb-Ghion Specialized teaching Hospital NICU, February, 2022-April, 2023

Characteristics Pre-Intervention Post-Intervention
# % # %
Age of Newborn Less than 24 hours 116 53.70% 118 54.60%
24 hours-72 hours 28 13% 31 14.40%
≥72 hours-7 days 34 15.70% 29 13.40%
≥7 days 38 17.60% 38 17.60%
Sex of the newborn Male 142 65.70% 128 59.30%
Female 74 34.30% 88 40.70%
Gestational Age Very Preterm 17 7.90% 10 4.60%
Late Preterm 50 23.10% 53 24.50%
Term 146 67.60% 139 64.40%
Post-term 3 1.40% 14 6.50%
Birth Weight of Newborn Extremely LBW 2 1% 0 0
Very LBW 17 7.90% 21 9.70%
LBW 54 25% 59 27.30%
Normal Birth Weight 140 64.80% 131 60.60%
Macrosomia 3 1.40% 5 2.30%
Maternal Age 15-24 years 60 27.80% 51 23.60%
24-34 years 129 59.70% 136 63%
>34 years 27 12.50% 29 13.40%
Mode of Delivery Spontaneous Vertex 149 69% 150 69.40%
Assisted Delivery 15 6.90% 5 2.30%
C/Section 52 24% 61 28.20%
Place of Delivery Home Institute 100 46.30% 97 44.90%
Other Institute 107 47.70% 113 52.30%
Home Delivery 9 4.20% 6 2.80%

Clinical Characteristics of Patients

The clinical Profile case mix of newborns enrolled in the study was stable throughout both the pre-and Post-Intervention period as characterized by comorbidity and Health Care associated Infection risk factors with an exception for Perinatal asphyxia and esophago-Gastro-Intestinal surgical disorders which had decreased by about a half and Meconium aspiration Syndrome which had doubled during Post-Intervention period. Detailed Clinical Parameters are described in Table 2.

Table 2: Clinical characteristics of Neonates across study phases: Bahir Dar University Tibebe-Ghion Specialized teaching Hospital NICU, February 2022-April 2023.

Characteristics Pre-Intervention Post-Intervention
# % # %
Comorbidity Yes 209 96.80% 208 9630.00%
No 7 3% 8 3.70%
Comorbidity Types Syndromic/Chromosome 12 5.60% 11 5.10%
TORCHS 6 2.80% 2 1.00%
Perinatal Asphyxia 19 8.80% 10 4.60%
Necrotizing Enterocolitis 9 4.20% 9 4.20%
Esophago-Gastro-Intestinal 24 11.10% 11 5.10%
Renal Diseases 8 3.70% 3 1.40%
Respiratory Distress Syndrome 35 16.20% 33 15.30%
Cardiac Disorders 8 3.70% 10 4.60%
Sepsis 141 65% 165 76.40%
Neurologic Disorders 15 6.90% 18 8.30%
Bleeding 25 12% 19 8.80%
Meconium Aspiration Syndrome 14 6.50% 24 11.10%
Neonatal Hyperbilirubinemia 42 19.40% 33 15.30%
Others 30 13.90% 30 13.90%

Characteristics of Health Care Associated Infections

The proportion of health care-associated infections across the study phases were 13% and 5% in phases 1 and 2, respectively. Blood stream Infections are the leading across the study period. The proportion of Health Care associated infection among term neonates has reduced markedly compared to the other categories of neonates. Table 3 shows the number of infected neonates and the distribution of health care associated infections across the study phases.

Table 3: Health Care associated infections characteristics across study phases: Bahir Dar University Tibebe-Ghion Specialized teaching Hospital NICU, February 2022-April 2023.

Characteristics Pre-Intervention Post-Intervention
# % # %
Health Care Associated Infection Yes 28 13.00% 11 5.00%
No 188 87% 205 95.00%
Site of Health Care Associated Infection Blood Stream Infection/BSI 13 46.4% 5 45.50%
Pneumonia 7 25.00% 1 9.10%
Surgical Site Infection 1 3.60% 0 0.00%
Skin and Soft tissue Infections 0 0.00% 1 9.10%
Meningitis 7 25.00% 4 36.30%
HCAIs against Gestational Age Term 15 53.60% 4 36.30%
Very Preterm 6 21.40% 4 36.30%
Late Preterm 7 25.00% 3 27.40%
Post term 0 0% 0 0.00%

Risk factors associated with Health Care Associated Infection

Comorbidities like Necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) and Esophago-Gastro-Intestinal surgical disorders, and Invasive Procedures like Continuous Positive Air way Pressure (CPAP) are strongly associated with Health Care associated infection with adjusted Odds ratio of 10.8 (1.28, 91.4); 26.5 (2.7, 258) and 25.3 (2.1, 300) respectively. The impact of the intervention remained significant after adjustment for possible confounders (See Table 4 for details).

Table 4: Factors associated with Acquisition of Health Care-Associated Infection among Newborns: Crude and Adjusted Odds ratio-Bahir Dar University, Tibebe-Ghion Hospital, NICU, February 2022 to May 2023.

Characteristics HCAI p-value Crude OR, 95% CI p-value Adjusted OR, 95% CI
Yes No  
Age of Newborn <24 hours 2600.00% 208 - 1 0.376 1
24 hours to 72 hours 300% 56 <0.001 18.67 (5.84, 59.64) 0.609 1.74 (0.21, 14.54)
≥72 hours to <7 days 300.00% 60 <0.001 20.00 (6.27, 63.68) 0.594 0.48 (0.03, 7.29)
≥7 days 700.00% 69 <0.001 9.86 (4.53, 21.45) 0.177 0.21 (0.02, 2.02)
Gender Male 2200.00% 248 - 1 - 1
Female 1700.00% 145 <0.001 8.53 (5.16, 14.09) 0.781 0.84 (0.24, 2.97)
Gestational Age Term 1900.00% 266   1 0.704 1
Very Preterm 1000.00% 17 18.30% 1.70 (0.78, 3.71) 0.292 0.16 (0.01, 4.84)
Late Preterm 1000.00% 93 <0.001 9.30 (4.84, 17.85) 0.62 0.52 (0.04, 6.86)
Post term 0.00% 17 99.80% 2.56 (6.25, 7.94) 0.998 -
Birth Weight Normal 1600% 255 - 1 0.822 1
Macrosomia 100.00% 7 6.90% 7.00 (0.86, 56.89) 0.371 0.15 (0.01, 9.69)
LBW 1300% 100 <0.001 7.69 (4.32, 13.71) 0.551 0.47 (0.04, 5.77)
Very LBW 800.00% 30 0.10% 3.75 (1.72, 8.18) 0.396 0.25 (0.01, 6.09)
Extremely LBW 100.00% 1 100.00% 1.00 (0.06, 15.99) 0.998 -
Maternal Age 15-24 years 1100.00% 100 - 1 0.354 1
24-34 years 2600.00% 239 <0.001 9.19 (6.13, 13.78) 0.194 0.39 (0.09, 1.62)
>34 years 200.00% 54 <0.001 27.00 (6.58, 110.74) 0.983 0.98 (0.12, 8.30)
Mode of Delivery Spontaneous 2700% 272 - 1 0.589 1
Assisted 200.00% 18 0.30% 9.00 (2.09, 38.79) 0.33 0.31 (0.03, 3.27)
C/Section 1000% 103 <0.001 10.30 (5.38, 19.71) 0.831 1.19 (0.25, 5.69)
Place of Delivery Home Institute 2300.00% 174 - 1 0.179 1
Other Institute 1500.00% 205 <0.001 13.67 (8.09, 23.09) 0.165 4.05 (0.56, 29.16)
Home Delivery 100.00% 14 1.10% 14.00 (1.8, 106.5) 0.073 25.65 (0.74, 886.4)
NEC Yes 7 11   1 - 1
No 31 382 <0.001 11.94 (8.32, 17.12) 0.029 10.81 (1.28, 91.43)
Esophago-Gastro-Intestinal Disorder Yes 8 27 - 1 - 1
No 31 366 <0.001 11.81 (8.18, 17.04) 0.005 26.52 (2.724, 258.2)
Invasive: CPAP Yes 18 69 - 1 - 1
No 21 324 <0.001 15.43 (9.92, 23.99) 0.01 25.34 (2.14, 300)
New born Category Pre-Intervention 28 188 - 1 - 1
Post-Intervention 11 205 <0.001 18.64 (10.2, 34.2) 0.007 8.03 (1.8, 35.9)

 

Remark: We use Haldane’s Correction for the zero values (and these zero values are Computed in MS excel). For Adjusted Odds ratio; If p-value shows no significance, we jumped calculating Odds ratio for Zero value.

Impact of Quality Improvement Intervention through “The Model for Improvement Approach” on Health Care Associated Infection

The Change Ideas generated were implemented and monitored every two weeks as a process indicator under the umbrella categories; The WHO Hand hygiene Compliance Checklist, The WHO Infection Prevention and Control Assessment Framework (IPCAF) and the Recommended NICU Design Standards for level III and IV NICUs together with the Health Care associated Infection pattern [9-13]. The incidence of Health Care associated Infection was much higher (28%) before than after the intervention (11%) and is statistically significant (Figure 1). [p-value=0.007, Adjusted Odds ratio with 95% CI=8.03 (1.79, 35.97)] (Table 4).

Quality-Primary-Care-Trends

Figure 1: Trends of HCAI with implementation of change ideas/interventions: PDSA Cycle

The Quality Improvement Intervention was computed with run chart to determine its significance.

• Rule 1: Trends: Greater than five consecutive points are moving in the same direction.

• Rule 2: Shift: 6 consecutive points exist on one side of the median.

• Rule 3: Runs: A non-random pattern or signal of change is indicated by too few or too many runs or crossings of the median line. Data line crosses the median once. Total run will be rule 2. Comparing with a probability table, the total run is too few (Lower limit=3 and upper limit=9). All the rules show that the change is not occurring by chance and is statistically significant [16]. See Figure 2 below.

Quality-Primary-Care-Run

Figure 2: Run chart on health care associated infection reduction

A Chi-square test of independence was performed to examine the significance of health care quality improvement intervention on reduction of Health care associated infection rate. The finding was significant, X2 (Degree of Freedom=1, Sample Size=432)=8.2, p=004. This shows that the impact of the intervention remained significant after the intervention phase. (See Tables 4 and 5)

Table 5: Relative frequency of Newborns with Health Care associated Infections across the study period. Bahir Dar University, Tibebe-Ghion Hospital, NICU, February 2022 to May 2023.

  Presence of HCAIs Total
Yes No
Pre-Intervention Count 28 188 216
Expected Count 19.5 196.5 216
Post-Intervention Count 11 205 216
Expected Count 19.5 196.5 216
Total Count 39 393 432
Expected Count 39 393 432
Chi-Square Tests
    Value df Asymptotic Significance
(2-sided)
Exact Sig
(2-sided)
Exact Sig
(1-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 8.146 1 0.004 - -
Continuity Correctionb 7.216 1 0.007 - -
Likelihood ratio 8.4 1 0.004 - -
Fisher’s exact test - - - 0.007 0.003
Linear-by-Linear Association 8.127 1 0.004 - -
N of valid cases 432 - - - -

Discussion

The results of this pre-post-Interventional study indicate that abiding with Infection prevention and control practices, Hand Hygiene practice implementation and re-enforcing the recommended minimum standards of NICU seems to impact on Health care associated infection reduction. To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first of its kind to assess the impact of Hand Hygiene compliance, the WHO Infection Prevention Guideline implementation and NICU Design Standardization on reduction of Health Care associated Infection in the NICU all together in a single study through “the Model for Quality Improvement Approach”. Implementation of these change Ideas/Interventions has significantly reduced the health care associated Infection incidence which was witnessed both during the Intervention phase (Run chart, Figure 2) and at the end of the study, Phase 3 [X2 (Degree of Freedom=1, Sample Size=432)=8.2, p=004]. Comorbidities like Necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) and Esophago-Gastro-Intestinal surgical disorders (Surgical Intervention and Long stay), and Invasive Procedures like Continuous Positive Air way Pressure (CPAP) are strongly associated with Health Care associated infection with adjusted Odds ratio of 10.8 (1.28, 91.4); 26.5 (2.7, 258) and 25.3 (2.1, 300) respectively. This is in line with other researches done previously [33-35]. This increased risk can be explained by the invasiveness of the interventions and expected prolonged stay in the unit as it is expected from the diseases nature. Bloodstream infection was the main site for HCAI in neonates in our study (46.4 and 45.5%, Pre-and Post- Intervention) which is in line with other study done in Egypt [35-38].

This interventional study finding will help in achieving the WHO’s major priority agenda to Reduce the risk of HCAIs faced by populations in developing countries as a spring board for further scale up of implementation and HCAI reduction in our country and elsewhere [8]. This succuss also changes the attitude of the clients to favour modern medical care as HCAIs ruin patient expectations of quality medical care and increase negativity towards the formal health system in favour of other options, especially since the costs of HCAIs are borne by the patients themselves in many developing countries [6]. In addition; by reducing the HCAIs, we can decrease unnecessary pain and suffering of patients and their families, prolonged hospital stays and cost to the health system [39]. This reduction in HCAIs helps us to reflect the extent of health care quality improvement in the health care system in the unit [3].

Conclusion

Although it is important to generate additional scientific evidence for the impact of evidence based quality improvement interventions on Health Care associated infection rates in health care settings, our results indicate that improved clinical practices reduce the risk of health care-associated infection. This study has revealed that implementation of Infection Prevention and Control practice, Hand Hygiene Compliance and adopting the minimum NICU Design standards were associated with a significant decrease in infection rates among the newborns admitted to NICU of various reasons. It also represents a step forward toward improved neonatal care.

Recommendations

Lessons learnt shall be shared with other service provision sites via intra/inter-facility experience sharing and other dissemination modalities.

Implementing this quality Improvement intervention at larger scale would make facilities, Health care providers and the customers beneficiary in terms of reducing the infections acquired while providing/receiving medical care at facility level.

Quality improvement interventions are not a one stop shot activities. Hence, maintaining the momentum at the unit is imperative in order to enhance the quality health care provision.

Hospital infection control strategies should be strengthened to reduce the burden of HCAIs.

Limitations

The generalizability of this study is limited as it is a single site Interventional study. Because the intervention was multimodal, it is therefore impossible to assess the relative efficacy of each components of the intervention. It also needs additional research in different patient population as the open level intervention method might have distorted the observed outcome.

Acknowledgement

We thank the Health Care providers of the neonatal unit of Bahir Dar University, Tibebe-Ghion Specialized Teaching Hospital for their support to the project and commitment to continue the momentum in providing quality health care at the unit.

Conflict Of Interest

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.

References

Citation: Gelaw TT, Gessesse AA, Yehuala AA, Belay YG, Tilahun SF, et al. (2023) Reducing Health Care Associated Infections in a Neonatal Intensive Care Unit through Quality Improvement Approach, Tibebe Ghion Specialized Teaching Hospital, Bahir Dar University, Bahir Dar, Ethiopia-Mirror of the Health Care Quality. Qual Prim Care. 31:37.

Copyright: © 2023 Gelaw TT, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.